The start of the Premier League 2025/26 campaign is proving far more turbulent than expected for Manchester City. Under Pep Guardiola, the reigning champions have long been synonymous with dominance in England, but a late collapse at the Amex Stadium against Brighton has only fueled the sense of crisis.

How Did the Match Unfold at the Amex?

Manchester City controlled the first half, creating multiple clear chances with Erling Haaland once again the focal point in attack. The Norwegian striker combined well with Tijani Reijnders and Rodri, and eventually found the breakthrough after 30 minutes, finishing a scrappy move assisted by Omar Marmoush to make it 0-1.

Despite their dominance, City failed to extend their lead, leaving the door open for the hosts. After the break, Fabian Hürzeler’s tactical changes injected energy into Brighton, pushing the Seagulls higher up the pitch and shifting momentum.

Brighton’s Response: Milner and Gruda Seal the Comeback

The equalizer arrived when a handball by Matheus Nunes was punished with a penalty. Veteran midfielder James Milner converted coolly from the spot to level the score at 1-1.

Just as City looked set to salvage a point, Kaoru Mitoma broke free on the left and delivered a precise assist to Brajan Gruda, who powered home the winner in the 89th minute. The German’s strike sparked wild celebrations at the Amex, sealing a famous 2-1 victory for Brighton.

What Does This Defeat Mean for Manchester City?

The loss marks City’s second defeat in their first three Premier League matches—something not seen since the 2004/05 season. After opening with a convincing win over Wolverhampton, Guardiola’s side has now suffered back-to-back defeats to Tottenham (0-2) and Brighton, who started the weekend in the relegation zone.

The slow start, combined with a lack of clinical finishing and a noticeable dip in performance compared to previous campaigns, raises serious concerns for the champions. Guardiola remains winless against Brighton boss Fabian Hürzeler, with one draw and now one defeat.

A City Side That No Longer Intimidates

The aura of invincibility surrounding Manchester City appears to be fading. This latest defeat not only dents their standing in the table but also shakes the confidence of a squad that once looked unstoppable in both England and Europe. Guardiola now faces the challenge of reigniting a team that suddenly feels vulnerable.