Amid continued speculation, former City midfielder Dietmar Hamann has openly questioned whether the legendary manager still possesses the hunger and influence needed to capture another Premier League crown.

After nearly a decade at the Etihad Stadium, Guardiola’s new deal signals his intention to push on despite a mixed 2024–25 season where City finished third, falling short of their usual title-winning standards.

The Spaniard acknowledged the challenges ahead, emphasizing his love for the club and determination to uplift the team despite recent setbacks, including a run of consecutive losses across competitions.

However, pundits and former players have grown vocal about his reduced impact. Hamann told Goal, “All good things eventually come to an end... I’m uncertain if he still has the drive,” reflecting a wider skepticism over whether Guardiola can still inspire City to dominate English football as he once did.

New Contract as a Statement and Challenge

Signing the contract can also be seen as a strategic move by Guardiola to “shut people up,” reinforcing his presence amid swirling doubts.

With a squad boasting talents like Erling Haaland and Rodri, and with potential squad reinforcements ahead, he remains equipped with resources to mount a serious title challenge. 

Yet the competition from Liverpool, Arsenal, and others continues to intensify, making the Premier League more difficult than ever to conquer. Guardiola’s ability to adapt tactically and motivate a rapidly evolving squad will be pivotal in determining whether this contract extension results in further silverware. 

The Verdict: Hope and Uncertainty

While some see Guardiola’s renewal as a positive signal for Manchester City’s sustained success, others highlight it as a final opportunity to prove his enduring greatness at the top level.

The coming seasons will test not only Guardiola’s tactical mastery but his capacity to reignite passion and leadership that has at times appeared to wane.

With a supportive ownership and devoted fanbase behind him, Guardiola’s quest for another Premier League title remains alive, but surrounded by a cloud of doubt that only time can clear.