Injury or Precaution? Bernardo Silva Raises Questions in Portugal
The midfielder left Portugal's training camp due to physical discomfort, but Real Madrid already have him available. Portugal's team doctor was forced to explain the decision.
The situation surrounding Bernardo Silva has sparked controversy in Portugal. The midfielder left the national team camp because of muscle discomfort, but just days later, it emerged that he would be available to play for Real Madrid.
The midfielder experienced discomfort in the back of his thigh after playing the closing minutes of Portugal's 4-1 defeat to Denmark on November 14. Following an assessment by the national team's medical staff, he was ruled out of the UEFA Nations League match against Wales.
However, subsequent tests in Madrid ruled out a structural injury. The player was cleared to be available for Saturday's match against Celta Vigo, raising questions about his early departure from the national team.
Portugal's Doctor Defends the Decision
Following the criticism, José Carlos Noronha, the Portuguese Football Federation's medical director, addressed reporters in Cardiff to explain why Bernardo Silva had been released despite subsequent tests revealing no injury.
The specialist explained that muscle discomfort can occur even when ultrasounds and MRI scans show no visible damage.
"These muscle pains and contractures, even when ultrasounds and MRIs are negative, can develop into complete tears a few days later," Noronha explained.
He also warned that allowing a player to compete immediately after experiencing such symptoms could increase the risk of a more serious injury.
According to the doctor, ruling Bernardo out of the Wales match was a necessary precaution, regardless of the results of the tests conducted by Real Madrid.

Why Can He Play on Saturday?
Noronha explained that there is an important distinction between experiencing muscle discomfort and suffering a muscle fiber tear.
According to his assessment, Bernardo Silva had a functional muscle problem without evidence of structural damage, requiring several days of recovery before returning to competitive action.
The doctor noted that MRI scans performed too early can produce negative results even when an injury is beginning to develop. For that reason, the medical staff considered playing against Wales, just three days after the discomfort appeared, an unnecessary risk.
"Given the type of discomfort Bernardo experienced, the procedure was correct. We informed the national team coach that he was not fit to play," he said.
He also clarified that recovering in time for Saturday would be consistent with the usual recovery period for this type of problem.
"It's perfectly normal for him to play on Saturday," he concluded.
Good News for Mourinho
While the controversy continues in Portugal, Real Madrid welcomed the results of the medical tests.
Bernardo Silva has become an important player for José Mourinho, particularly through his partnership with Aurélien Tchouaméni in midfield.
The Portuguese midfielder had started Real Madrid's previous five matches, and his potential absence would have created another problem for the coach ahead of LaLiga's return.
However, everything suggests he will be available to face Celta Vigo at the Santiago Bernabéu on Saturday, November 21.
For now, Portugal's medical staff have made their position clear: Bernardo Silva was not fit to face Wales, but that does not mean he could not recover in time for Real Madrid's next match.
Key Details of Bernardo Silva's Situation
- Portugal departure: He was released after experiencing muscle discomfort following the match against Denmark and was ruled out against Wales.
- Negative medical tests: Examinations conducted in Madrid found no structural injury, although that does not invalidate the discomfort he experienced.
- Available for Mourinho: The midfielder was cleared to be available for Real Madrid's match against Celta Vigo on November 21.
Subscribe to watch beIN SPORTS LIVE




















