After a season marked by solid but occasionally stretched defensive performances, Atalanta is eager to bolster their squad depth, focusing on the left-back position.

With continued transfer business underway—such as progressing talks over striker Rodrigo Muniz—the club’s sporting director Tony D’Amico has identified a left-back signing as a priority to support coach Juric’s high-intensity tactical demands. 

Among the candidates, two Premier League players have emerged as leading contenders: Ian Maatsen of Aston Villa and Tyrell Malacia from Manchester United (currently loaned to PSV Eindhoven).

Both 23-year-olds offer attacking prowess combined with defensive tenacity, fitting the mold for Gian Piero Gasperini’s style that combines fluid offense with a resilient backline.

Comparing the Candidates: Maatsen vs Malacia

Ian Maatsen has impressed since moving to Aston Villa, showcasing pace, creativity, and a willingness to bomb forward, while maintaining solid defensive contributions.

His performances in the Premier League have drawn widespread attention, making him a valuable asset whose potential Atalanta sees as a great fit for Serie A’s tactical demands. 

Tyrell Malacia, at Manchester United, has gained valuable experience under intense scrutiny, combining defensive discipline with the ability to support attacks.

Though sometimes criticized for inconsistency, his work rate and adaptability make him an intriguing option for Atalanta, especially given his Champions League experience, which would be valuable for Atalanta’s continental ambitions. 

Atalanta faces a decision balancing Maatsen’s dynamic attacking abilities against Malacia’s higher-level experience and versatility.

Future Outlook and Transfer Prospects

Negotiations are reportedly underway, with Atalanta evaluating not just sporting qualities but also transfer fees and wage demands. Ligue 1 winger Diego Moreira remains another left-side option under consideration, signaling the club’s intent to ensure multiple avenues to strengthen their squad. 

The club’s approach underscores a strategic effort to compete both domestically and in European competitions, ensuring depth in key areas of their flexible system.

Maatsen or Malacia coming to Bergamo would provide not only defensive solidity but also vital attacking width crucial for Juric’s high-press system.

As the 2025 summer transfer window progresses, Atalanta’s choice will reflect both their immediate tactical needs and longer-term squad planning, with the left-back spot one of the pivotal decisions shaping their competitiveness in Serie A and Europe.