A debate that reaches El Clásico

At 18, Franco Mastantuono finds himself at the heart of one of Real Madrid’s biggest debates of the season: should he start against Barcelona in El Clásico on October 26 at the Santiago Bernabéu?

According to a survey published by Diario AS, Madridistas are far from unanimous. Some fans argue the Argentine prodigy deserves to start after his impressive performances under Xabi Alonso, while others believe the pressure of such a massive stage could be too much, too soon.

“There shouldn’t even be a debate — the one who shouldn’t start is Mastantuono. Güler has earned it, and Bellingham is essential for a Madrid that wants to win everything,” said one supporter quoted by AS.

The upcoming Clásico isn’t just another match. Real Madrid haven’t beaten Barcelona since the spring of 2024, back when Carlo Ancelotti was still in charge. Four straight defeats — including heavy losses and cup finals — have left fans desperate for redemption.

A rising star under pressure

Despite the noise, Mastantuono remains one of Alonso’s most trusted young players. His vision, technical touch, and ability to connect with Kylian Mbappé and Vinícius Jr. have made him a unique weapon in Madrid’s new attacking setup. But El Clásico is different — a match where composure and experience often outweigh raw talent.

The Argentine is also up against history: since Ángel Di María in 2014, no Argentine has started for Real Madrid in a Clásico. That fact alone fuels both the excitement and the scrutiny around his possible inclusion.

Between promise and patience

Mastantuono represents the new era at Real Madrid — youthful, fearless, and immensely talented. Yet, before the Clásico, Alonso’s men face two key tests: a league match against Getafe and a crucial Champions League clash with Juventus. Those fixtures will likely determine whether Mastantuono earns his shot at Barcelona.

For now, the debate remains open. Franco Mastantuono has become the “apple of discord” among Madridistas — for some, the bright future of the club; for others, a prodigy who still has to wait for his big night.