During the LaLiga EA Sports Matchday 34 clash between Real Madrid and Celta Vigo, a challenge by Jude Bellingham sparked controversy and debate. The English midfielder went in with his studs up on Fer López, leading many to argue that he should have been sent off with a straight red card.

Was It a Sending-Off?

The incident took place shortly before halftime with Real Madrid leading on the scoreboard. Bellingham slid in aggressively, showing his studs and catching his opponent on the ankle. Referee Gil Manzano, who was well-positioned, opted to show only a yellow card—a decision that immediately generated strong reactions from fans, pundits, and refereeing analysts.

VAR Archive's Take

On social media, the expert account @ArchivoVAR shared images of the tackle and explained why it wasn’t punished with a red card:

Was Bellingham’s tackle on Fer López a red card?

NO.

Although the tackle involved studs up, there was no full-force impact or excessive intensity on the opponent's ankle.

The contact was deemed a graze rather than a violent challenge, prompting Gil Manzano to issue a yellow card.

The post includes four still images capturing the exact moment of contact, showing that Bellingham’s boot brushed the ankle but didn’t apply dangerous pressure or cause significant impact.

What Does the Rulebook Say?

According to the refereeing protocol, a studs-up challenge may be punished with a red card if it involves high intensity, endangers the safety of the opponent, or is made with excessive force. In this case, neither the referee nor the VAR deemed those criteria to be met.

The incident has divided opinions: some believe the yellow was fair based on the minimal contact; others argue that the manner and intent of the tackle alone merited a sending-off. What’s certain is that Bellingham will be available for the next Clásico—something that would not have been the case had he been suspended.