Jamal Musiala's serious injury during the quarterfinal match between Bayern Munich and Paris Saint-Germain in the Club World Cup not only raised medical alarms, but also sparked a debate over the play that caused it. While Manuel Neuer harshly criticized Gianluigi Donnarumma for his challenge, Real Madrid goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois stepped in to defend his fellow shot-stopper.

Courtois responds to Neuer: “You can’t blame a goalkeeper like that”

The play that left Musiala with a serious left ankle injury was described by Neuer as “an unnecessary challenge.” The Bayern captain believed that Donnarumma took a risk that could have been avoided and was also frustrated by the fact that the PSG keeper didn’t immediately check on Musiala’s condition.

However, Courtois, who had just helped Real Madrid advance to the semifinals with a 3–2 win over Borussia Dortmund in New Jersey, had a different perspective and defended Donnarumma.

“Blaming Donnarumma for what happened seems excessive to me. We, as goalkeepers, go for the ball, just like strikers come at us without thinking if they might hit us,” said the Belgian.

Courtois made it clear that the incident wasn’t intentional:

“It was just very bad luck. Donnarumma jumps for the ball, and at that moment Musiala turns and his foot gets caught. These things happen. I’m sure Donnarumma feels terrible about it.”

The Madrid keeper urged for understanding in these types of situations, which, although dramatic, are part of the game:

“When it’s your teammate, it hurts more and you’re quick to criticize, but the goalkeeper had to go for it. From his position, it wasn’t an avoidable play.”

With Musiala now ruled out for several months after being diagnosed with a fractured fibula and dislocated ankle, the debate over responsibility in these kinds of plays continues. What’s clear is that between Neuer’s criticism and Courtois’ defense, football once again shows how a single moment can divide opinions—even among the game’s top goalkeepers.