Anticipation for the September 13 bout between Canelo Álvarez and Terence Crawford grows by the day, but now a new issue has stirred controversy. The appointment of the judges for the fight has raised eyebrows, as they are the same ones who were at the center of debate in Manny Pacquiao’s fight against Mario Barrios, where the Filipino legend ended up with a surprising draw in his return to the ring.

The questioned judges: a worrying precedent

The officials assigned to score the fight will be Tim Cheatham, Max DeLuca, and Steve Weisfeld—the very same trio who declared the Pacquiao-Barrios clash a draw earlier this year.

That decision was heavily criticized, as much of the specialized press and several former boxers felt Pacquiao had done enough to win. With more power punches landed and clear control of most rounds, Pacquiao seemed deserving of what would have been his 13th world title. However, Barrios’ late resistance and his constant use of the jab were highly valued by the judges, tipping the scales toward an unexpected draw.

This precedent raises concerns ahead of Canelo vs Crawford, especially since the scoring tendencies of these judges could influence both fighters’ strategies.

How it could affect Canelo vs Crawford

Cheatham, DeLuca, and Weisfeld’s judging style tends to favor control and consistency over sheer aggression. That could play into Canelo Álvarez’s hands, as he is known for his patient, surgical style of boxing, focused on ring control. His jab and ability to dictate the pace are elements these judges have historically rewarded.

For Terence Crawford, the scenario looks different. With a lighter frame compared to Álvarez, his strategy may revolve around maintaining a high work rate and leaning on his stamina in the later rounds—much like Barrios did against Pacquiao. Going for an early knockout could drain him, so staying consistent and precise will be key to impressing the judges.

With the fresh controversy from the Pacquiao-Barrios fight still in memory, the appointment of these judges puts extra scrutiny on the potential outcome of this showdown. If the fight goes the full twelve rounds, their scorecards will be under intense examination from fans and the international media.